Sunday, August 2, 2009

Grit Over Smarts for Success

This Sunday's Ideas section in the Boston Globe contains an article about research on an underappreciated mental quality that Angela Duckworth, a psychologist at the UPenn, has termed "grit". Grit is a quality of stick-with-it-ness that seems to be common to those who are successful in life. More specifically, researchers are accumulating evidence that grit is a better predictor of future success (not explicitly defined in the article) than more conventional measures of aptitude or potential such as IQ. Indeed, some researchers argue that focusing on IQ may not only be misleading, but may in fact set a person up for failure. The implications for education are, of course, important.

The value of understanding grit seems quite practical. The article spends some time on the search for ways of better measuring grit, and more importantly, ways to encourage or instill it. There are at least two implications from this article, however, that I find a little disturbing.
  • Implication #1: Success is achieved through narrow and sustained focus, while lack of success happens from wandering interests. The article states: "While parents and teachers have long emphasized the importance of being well-rounded - this is why most colleges require students to take courses in all the major disciplines, from history to math - success in the real world may depend more on the development of narrow passions."
This issue is at the heart of the debate on the purpose and value of a liberal arts education. If one sees a college or university education as simply job training with the objective of higher pay and status, then yes, one might be better served by simply choosing a subject and studying only that: no science for English majors, and no Literature or History for Biology majors. Of course, one should still ask: is this form of 'success' the purpose of education? It's interesting to note that the article suggests that MCAS and similar tests may be missing the point by focusing on IQ, but I think that the point is still being missed.
  • Implication #2: Success in life is based on an individual's traits, not political or social circumstances.
This one is always a doozy. The second half of this implication is never actually stated in the article, but it should be clear enough. More importantly, I think this implication deserves more scrutiny because it is something that too easily resonates with the American myth of "pulling yourself up from your bootstraps," and is therefore more likely to be embraced uncritically. Social and political context are certainly not everything, but there is too much evidence from history and the social sciences demonstrating, repeatedly, that for the vast majority of human beings, the social and political hand you are dealt is most important. If anything, it is important to recognize ideas or perspectives that may serve to de-politicize important social issues. We already give ourselves and our political representatives too many excuses to duck and cover from complicated things.

My point is not to dismiss or even diminish the idea of 'grit' as an important ingredient for success. Rather, I hope that we can extract its more useful possibilities without stretching the meaning to justify other, less constructive, agendas.

You can you can take the 'grit survey' at www.gritstudy.com to get a measure of your own grittiness.

Friday, July 31, 2009

Climate Change Squared

On Thursday I attended two very different and similar meetings on climate change.

Climate Change Meeting 1
The first meeting was with the Roxbury Environmental Empowerment Project (REEP) - a youth-led environmental justice organization based in Boston's Roxbury neighborhood. I visited with them at ACE in order to help them with their presentation on global warming. They have their script down pretty well - concise and basically right. Not surprisingly, there were some kinks and some needed clarifications:
  1. The 'greenhouse effect' is actually a natural process. The problem is that we are over-enhancing it.
  2. Global warming and the ozone hole are two different problems (a lot of people seem to confuse these two issues).
  3. It's generally okay to use the terms 'climate change' and 'global warming' interchangeably, but 'global warming' should not be interpreted to mean it's just going to get warmer. The effects of climate change are not the same everywhere. The western US is getting drier and hotter, while the northeast is getting a lot more precipitation and stronger storms both in summer AND winter (including more intense ice storms).
  4. The biggest immediate and chronic impacts on urban communities are heat stress and worsened air pollution. Heat stress is deadly for the very young, the very old, and the chronically ill - especially if you don't have A/C, have under-treated health conditions because you lack money or health insurance, and are stuck in a concrete environment with little or poorly maintained vegetation. Add to that the fact that smog - especially ground-level ozone and particulate matter - are enhanced by warm weather. Worse smog can be deadly, if not downright unpleasant, to the very young, the very old, and the chronically ill ... you get it. Houston, we have a problem.
Unlike most organizations raising the alarm about climate change, REEP is primarily interested in the meaning of environmental problems for vulnerable communities. It also means that they are looking for opportunities in this crisis. The last point is an interesting one, and it overlaps in interesting ways with the other meeting.

Climate Change Meeting 2
The second meeting (to which I arrived late because it was hard to stop talking over at ACE) was with the state's Climate Change Adaptation Advisory Committee. I've been attending the Key Infrastructure subcommittee. I need to thank Gene Benson from ACE, who was actually appointed by the Governor to the Committee, for suggesting me as a participant, as well as Brian Brodeur at DEP, for vouching for me to the subcommittee chair. The subcommittee meetings have been where the action is, but this big meeting was an opportunity to hear what all the other subcommittees have been doing regarding: coastal zones, public infrastructure, health and human welfare, terrestrial habitats, government and private business, etc. Each of the subcommittee chairs summarized their work to date, most of which had to do with identifying key vulnerabilities and suggested strategies. However, the point, as the Committee Chair reminded us, was not to "get into the weeds" on the details.

What's interesting to me, is the way in which many of the participants have seized on this crisis assessment as an opportunity for meaningful change - not just a panicked reaction to some imminent threat. As Ed Kuntz from DEP put it, we have the opportunity to change the whole paradigm of land use, economic development, and environmental management. Two strategies in particular stand out (at least to me):
  1. Incorporating "nature-based" adaptation and mitigation strategies. This is similar to the idea of using "green infrastructure." Basically, this means recognizing and making use of the amazing variety and robustness of "services" that natural ecosystems provide. For example: wetlands for water filtration and buffering from storm surge; trees to provide cooling and absorption of excess water; open/green space to allow infiltration of rain and prevent excessive runoff and flooding, etc. Bob Zimmerman of the Charles River Watershed Association did an amazing presentation for the Infrastructure subcommittee on this issue.
  2. Using the lens of community vulnerability to set priorities and design strategies. At a minimum, this means identifying those communities that are exposed to hazards AND less able to handle or recover from them - a concept known as resilience. It also means that when you look to clean things up, say by eliminating inefficient industrial practices or technologies, you begin by cleaning up the dirtiest in the most impacted neighborhoods. Finally, the lens of community vulnerability forces us to look for ways to reduce vulnerability and enhance resilience by changing the very conditions that create vulnerability and low resilience - low socioeconomic status, geographic and social segregation, political influence, etc. First step: direct job and restructuring opportunities (i.e. stimulus funds) to communities most in need.
For all its threats, climate change presents a fascinating problem and a unique opportunity to redirect our society. Find more information on the Committee's website as well as notes from the public meetings. A final report to the state legislature is due December 2009.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Unexpected Recognition

About a week ago, the Chair of our Department called me into his office with little warning. I don't know why, but I always feel nervous when he does this - like getting called to the Principal's office. The President's Office (of the school, not the country) had called to ask that I attend an awards ceremony at the Hawthorne Hotel in recognition of my help on mapping Salem Woods. This was something I had worked on with Alan Young in Biology and one of my graduate students - Jen Sumael - three years ago! I agreed, of course, and contacted Jen to make sure she attended as well.
On Tuesday, the Hawthorne Hotel honored Chris Burke of the Friends of Salem Woods, and Salem State College, for our work in preserving a place of historical significance - Salem Woods (you can read about the event itself on the Hawthorne Hotel's blog). Alan Young was not able to attend, so President Meservey attended in order to receive the award on his behalf. When she spoke at the event, she described how her office had received a call from the Hawthorne Hotel announcing their desire to recognize Salem State for work on the Salem Woods map and brochure. The funny thing was that no one seemed to know who exactly at the College had done this work. It took the President's office a little while to figure it out and track us down. In any case, it was a nice surprise.

Sunday, May 17, 2009

2009 Undergraduate Commencement

On Saturday I attended the 2009 undergraduate ceremony (the 199th for SSC!), along with Larry Goss, John Hayes, Steve Matchak, and Steve Young. Over 1,600 graduates this year! We had 19 from Geography, which is about normal. U.S. Rep John Tierney received an honorary degree and gave the commencement speech, which was remarkably short. I was particularly impressed, however, by the speech (or greeting) delivered by the President of the Student Government Association Quin Gonnell. Quinn was a graduating senior (and by all appearances, a young man), but he came across a like a seasoned leader. Mr. Gonnell hails from Lawrence, and by his own account, a not-so-privileged background. He is an exemplar of a student whose success was critically dependent upon a second chance and the support of people who maintain faith in the ability of remarkable individuals to exceed expectations.

Friday, May 15, 2009

2009 Graduate Commencement


I had the pleasure of attending the graduate commencement late Thursday afternoon. Keith Ratner and I marched with other faculty in our robes. It was a fairly large graduation - several hundred graduates. We had a particularly large cohort of graduates this year from the M.S. Geo-Information Science program - 8 in all (though the program listed one other who was not quite done yet). The highlight of this year's ceremony was clearly the commencement speech by Jonathan Kozol, one of the two recipients of honorary degrees in humane letters. Mr. Kozol is a longtime educator and children's advocate who has written numerous award-winning books on the plight of underprivileged children in particular. Though I think most of us were more impressed by the fact that he was a close friend of the late and beloved Mr. Rogers. Mr. Kozol was funny and moving, and surprisingly, fiery in his critique of the narrowing and regimentation of education that is happening in response to standardized testing (i.e. MCAS in Massachusetts). He implored the graduates - and the rest of us - to not let go of the spontanaity and creativity and humanness that makes good and worhwhile education.
After the ceremony we met with our graduates in a reception - very happy (and relieved) individuals.